BNP and UKIP aside, politicians and party activists across the spectrum abhor racism. The BNP courts it openly and UKIP finds it far more effective to use the dog whistle of immigration. You’ll find unreconstructed attitudes around race, gender, sexuality and the rest especially amongst the older generation, of course. Within the boundaries set by human imperfection, though, most folk involved day-to-day in politics confront racism where they see it.

Of course there’s plenty that’s discriminatory, in all the ways, about our society and our institutions. Most politicians and activists of all shades try to do their best to change that. In fact, for a lot of them that’s the main reason they got involved in politics in the first place. One of the things that’s racist about our society, however, is an uncomfortably large minority of the voters.

Right now, whether they admit it or not, all the parties in Scotland are organising themselves around the simple binary divide of Scottish unionism versus Scottish independence. The model of independence chosen by the SNP and the Greens makes it in their interest to be as inclusive as it’s possible to be. And since they’re in charge in that devolved part of Scotland, and unlike the model the UK chose for the EU referendum, if you’re in Scotland you’re as much a Scot as anyone else regardless of your present nationality or anything else.  Obvious benefits extend from this philosophy, but it does mean these parties accept that they are less attractive to racists.

On the unionist side, though, things are murkier. The BNP’s gone now, more or less, and the wheels are coming off UKIP. The Tories are bringing folk back from UKIP to the Tory fold by aping UKIP. So while it’s certainly unfair to claim that Tory politicians are racist, there’s no doubt that some are up for a bit of their own dog-whistle-blowing through deploying immigration as racism’s proxy.

But what of Scottish Labour? Well, Labour politicians don’t have a monopoly on this, but they go into politics to rid our world – or at least our own society – of injustice and inequality. Clearly, most Scots think they’re not to be trusted to do this job now or maybe ever, but few folk in their heart of hearts argue with that notion.

But take a look at a detail of early Feb’s Panelbase survey (here at the top of this interesting ’50 Days of Yes’ article….) for attitudes to immigration.

In answer to the dog-whistle question on immigration – “Broadly speaking, do you agree with or disagree with – ‘There is a problem with too much immigration in Scotland‘”; Scots as a whole (including DKs) agreed by a margin of 8 points that they do. Of 2014 No voters, this figure increased to a massive 27%. Meanwhile, for Yes voters it declined to  -12%.

The gap between 2014 unionists and 2014 independence supporters on the subject of immigration is a staggering 39 points. 

Of course, the great majority folk who are worried about immigration aren’t racists. But if you’re casting around for the racist vote, it’s the unionist pool you’ll want to fish in. Or to put it the other way – if you only fish in the unionist pool, you know you’re going to hook more racists.

Right now, the dominant narrative within the UK Labour Party is that it needs to concentrate on getting votes back from UKIP in ‘heartlands’ seats. We all know this is a vain attempt to mask its failure against the Tories, of course. But we also know that Scottish Labour is losing many voters to the Tories as well as the SNP. There is therefore a very serious risk that this ‘English heartlands’ imperative will transmogrify in Scotland into an attempt to be seen by working class Scottish unionists as more unionist than the Tories, with all the implications for ‘immigration’ and sectarianism that would bring.

Scottish Labour as the party of ultra-unionism (see last para)? Is that the way things are going?

Faced with unionist dogma amongst Labour’s present leaders, the many Labour voters with open minds need to chart a path towards realising their own social vision in an independent Scotland. Their leaders can follow on if they like. But, to be frank, if they pursue an ultra-unionist course they won’t be welcome.


Postscript (7 Mar)Jack (see comments) drew our attention to something he thought he’d read recently recently by a key Better Together figure.  We’ve found the article. It was published as a comment piece in The Daily Record last week. Look at the 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th last paragraphs. Leaving out the disingenuous, butter-wouldn’t-melt stuff Blair McDougall writes;

“Given that so many of the
undecided voters were so
 sceptical of immigration, why was there so little debate about it in 2014”? And; “I just wonder how with attitudes to the EU so driven by attitudes towards immigration and with Brexit being given as the material change that reopens the question of independence, could a debate on immigration be avoided”. 

So that’s clear enough. Folk like Blair McDougall want to make Indyref 2 all about immigration. Cue those dog-whistles.





8 Responses to If you’re looking for Scotland’s racist vote…..
  1. Always wanted to see Jimmie Smurfie chased by a guy in an egg costume.
    Also was Labour not an anti immigrant party when it began? Hardie ranted against Irish and in particular “Russian Poles”. These “Russian Poles” were in fact Lithuanians who he described as “diseased, dirty and smelling of olive oil”. It seems that parties trying to get a foot hold or retain a foot hold resort to base emotional subjects that inspire fear and hate.
    Perhaps the attempts to tar SNP or Yes supporters tells us more about the Labour Party’s future campaigns. Going for the racists and religious bigots votes. Pretending it’s really foreigners that are bigoted against White Protestants. Reverse bigotry claims are common in the USA because no one knows the facts.

  2. You can see it coming, Prince Boris will arrive and note that Turkey will be sending 50 Million people to Scotland. Köfti and Börek FTW.

    Racist ‘Yes’ commentary will appear from fresh eggs on twitter suddenly under the banner of ‘pasty blue white Scots for race supremacy’. Vitamin-D will be their drug of choice.

    A raft of stories on the BBC, Herald and Scotsman will vilify ‘Yes’ of course, but they are right – if its a new egg, or a facefart account, then its worth 10x as much as an elected Scottish indy friendly MP.

    I just wonder how they will get the egg/facefart account onto the Scottish Six sofa. Brown in fancy dress (or any other sad old lost former z-list celeb).

    • I don’t want to be too literalistic about this, but could attending the studios simply dressed as a huge egg work for Yes campaigners? There’d be the comedy effect to work around, granted, but this might at least enable some kind of parity of coverage.

  3. Spot on, Eric.
    A few weeks ago Blair McDougall was given column inches and slipped in that ‘immigration’ would be one of the key issues in the Second Self Determination Referendum.
    There are intolerant fascist racists lurking in every political party.
    I don’t think that the YES movement is predicting a Flower Power Peace and Love Independent Future.
    But McDougall’s wee xenophobic observation serves as a warning.
    Together Stronger will unashamedly ‘warn’ that unfettered immigration to Scotland will mushroom if we remain in the EU and EngWaland ‘take back control’.
    They’ll be taking our jobs, getting preferential treatments for council houses, jumping the NHS queue, and so on.
    Not all Labour politicians, especially the neo conservative Mandelson/Blair New Labour version came into politics for the Greater Good.
    I pondered ‘Projet Peur’ as an Independence weapon next time.
    It won’t be needed. As the Brexit negotiations falter, and Mad Max threatens to ‘No Deal’ walk away, swithering NO voters, some of whom might be institutionalised racists or bigots, may say: what’s more important to me. Having a job, a wage, security in an Independent Scotland within the EU, or do I apply to Vauxhall for a job in Ellesmere? I doubt that Peugot has taken Vauxhall Opel off GM’s hands, to expand its operation in England.
    Already car workers are on the telly worried about their jobs. Brexit, the Indian gift that keeps taking.

  4. Well said Mr Joyce.

  5. The article you link to in the piece, Eric, is absolutely splendid. May I re-post the link again in clear as a further recommendation?

    I was unaware of that blog. Another one to add to my favourites list!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *